Arch Reality gives spammers the edge

On the heels of my amazing discovery of the “PC Mesh Hide Files and Folders“:http://blog.nerdbucket.com/articles/2007/01/15/revolutionary-new-software software, I make yet another Awesome Software Discovery: “jcap”:http://www.archreality.com/jcap/!

CAPTCHA(Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart) technology is always trying to keep ahead of spam / bot technology. This is just another techno-arms race that will probably never end. But this company, “Arch Reality”:http://www.archreality.com, has devised a “clever” image-based CAPTCHA that is 100% javascript.

This Awesome Software Discovery is “special” because it may be the only CAPTCHA system that is run in the client’s browser exclusively. In most cases, you have to have server scripting (PHP, Ruby, Perl, ASP, etc) to process CAPTCHA information, which is a bit of a pain. You have to maintain state information to know that user X was shown picture Y and such. But with this system, All you need is a client running javascript! How awesome is that? Super easy to set up, even for a web novice.

Spammers, beware! As long as we have people like Arch Reality working on our side, your days are numbered!

…or are they?

Well, this is one of those theoretically sound ideas. Much like Communism and pyramid schemes. Any web programmer will notice very quickly that this is total BS. How do spammers operate? Do they single-handedly man a thousand computers simultaneously, working feverishly to send out their spam? NO. They automate everything they can. And let me tell you, when you automate something like a web-based form submission, the last thing you want to bother with is figuring out some javascript! So what do the spammers do? They fracking ignore it! Which leads us to a CAPTCHA that actually verifies that people who have a javascript-enabled browser are, in fact, real people. WOW.

This one blows my mind. PC Mesh has a pretty crappy concept, but these folks really take the cake! Arch Reality’s only saving grace is the disclaimer that came over a year after jcap’s release:

***NOTICE (01.10.2006): The developer assumes no liability with this resource and it is provided as is. This script is referred to as a “security development” because it can provide some minimal level of security. While it does seem to be an effective elementary form of security the developer does not claim that it is an impenetrable solution and thus the developer does not recommend implementing it for the protection of highly sensitive data.

And to me, even that disclaimer is full of crap. Their product will provide literally no security. If you want proof, hit their “demo page”:http://www.archreality.com/jcap/captcha.html, then disable javascript, then type ANYTHING YOU WANT, and click Submit.

Just like a JavaScript-ignoring bot, you too can break through this so-called security development with ease! I’d like to know where they got the idea that this garbage would be “effective” at anything other than pissing off clients! Almost makes me think Arch Reality is working for the spammers….

I’ve done a small amount of digging, and sadly there are people out there who use this product, and think it provides some measure of security. This kind of ignorance is so easily avoided if the people who write software would spend the half hour to research the actual problem they’re trying to solve.

If I can reach just one person, and that person keeps from hiring these horribly untalented hacks, I’ll feel this blog post was more than worthwhile.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.